Leak Check Identify the likely profit or tax leak to validate first.See what you get

The Tax Mistakes Business Owners Make, in the Order a CFO Checks Them

Light split rounded tiles beside the purple and dark Sora title The Tax Mistakes Owners Make, in the Order a CFO Checks.
On this page

Check for the costly ones in this order: are the books current, is anyone projecting this year's tax, are payroll taxes deposited, is owner pay structured correctly, are reimbursements and 1099s handled under the 2026 rules, does each owner have basis for what they're taking, and were the elections made on time. The order matters. Each check depends on the one before it, and the costliest mistakes are usually near the top, not in the clever strategies at the bottom.

Most lists of the biggest tax mistakes business owners make jump to missed deductions. Missed deductions are real, but you can't find them in books that are four months behind, and they don't matter much if the payroll account is short.

The checking order at a glance

# Check What goes wrong How bad it gets
1 Books current and reconciled Every later number is a guess Bad decisions on everything below
2 Projection and estimated payments Surprise April bill, underpayment interest Interest at 7% in Q4 2026, plus a cash crunch
3 Payroll tax deposits Withheld taxes used as working capital Personal liability for 100% of unpaid trust fund tax
4 Owner salary and benefits Salary too low, premiums off the W-2 Reclassified distributions, lost deductions
5 Reimbursements and 1099s No accountable plan, wrong 2026 thresholds Taxable "reimbursements," filing errors
6 Owner basis Losses or distributions beyond basis Disallowed losses, taxable distributions
7 Elections and deadlines PTET, retirement plans, timing moves missed The year's options close for good

1. Books that aren't current

This isn't a tax rule. It's the reason the rest of the list fails. If the books close 60 or 90 days late, nobody can project this year's taxable income in October, and every decision after that is made on last year's numbers.

Bennett's view is simple: a tax plan built on stale books is a guess. One of the published Bennett case studies, Chimney Scientist, describes an owner who went through six accountants in ten years and was consistently overpaying. That is what this mistake looks like from the inside.

2. No projection, estimates on autopilot

Owners of pass-through businesses pay the business's income tax personally, through estimated payments. The IRS estimated taxes page says sole proprietors, partners, and S corporation shareholders generally must make them if they expect to owe $1,000 or more.

Publication 505 sets the safe harbor at the smaller of 90% of this year's tax or 100% of last year's, rising to 110% of last year's if last year's AGI was above $150,000. The mistake is paying last year's number divided by four in a year when income is up sharply, then finding out in March. Underpayments accrue interest at the IRS underpayment rate, 7% for the fourth quarter of 2026, compounded daily.

A hypothetical shows why the safe harbor and the cash plan are different questions. An owner's 2025 federal tax was $90,000 and 2025 AGI was above $150,000, so paying 110%, or $99,000, in 2026 estimates avoids the underpayment penalty. If the business has a strong year and the 2026 tax comes to $160,000, the remaining $61,000 is still due in April. The safe harbor protects against the penalty. It doesn't keep $61,000 in the bank.

The fix is a quarterly projection. It's also the first deliverable to look for if you're deciding what tax planning should cost.

3. Payroll taxes used as working capital

When cash is tight, some owners pay vendors first and the IRS later. With withheld payroll taxes, that's the most expensive loan a business can take.

The IRS describes the Trust Fund Recovery Penalty as equal to the unpaid balance of the trust fund tax: withheld income tax plus the employees' share of FICA. It can be assessed against any responsible person with the duty and power to direct payment of those taxes, which includes owners and officers. Willfulness doesn't require bad intent. Paying other creditors while knowing payroll taxes are unpaid is enough of an indicator.

If the business can't make its payroll deposits, that's a cash-flow emergency, not a tax-timing choice.

You probably know which of these seven you haven't looked at in a while. If you'd like someone to check the list against your actual numbers, the Profit & Tax Leak Check points to the two or three items most likely to be costing you money.

4. Owner pay that doesn't hold up

For S corp owners, two mistakes show up together. The first is a salary set by habit, not by what the role would cost to replace. The IRS can reclassify distributions as wages when the shareholder's own services generate the revenue. Our guide to setting an S corp reasonable salary walks through the replacement-cost method.

The second is health insurance. The IRS S corporation compensation page says premiums paid for a more-than-2% shareholder belong in W-2 Box 1 wages, not Boxes 3 and 5. Leave them off and the owner's self-employed health insurance deduction is at risk.

5. Reimbursements and 1099s under the old rules

Reimbursements. An S corp owner who pays business costs personally has no deduction for them. The miscellaneous itemized deduction suspension in IRC §67 is now permanent. The company needs a written accountable plan, or a monthly "expense allowance" becomes taxable wages.

1099s. The 2026 Form 1099-MISC and 1099-NEC instructions raised the reporting threshold for nonemployee compensation and rents to $2,000 for tax years beginning after 2025, with inflation adjustments possible from 2027. Payments to corporations are generally exempt, but attorneys' fees are reportable even when paid to a corporation. Using the old $600 threshold for 2026 payments creates extra forms. The bigger mistake is a vendor file without W-9s, which makes the reporting impossible either way. Our article on the 2026 1099-NEC threshold covers the details.

6. Taking money out without basis

An S corporation shareholder can deduct losses and receive tax-free distributions only up to their basis in the stock and loans. The IRS says shareholders use Form 7203 to figure those limitations.

The mistake is nobody tracking it. An owner takes distributions in a year the company broke even, or deducts a loss without the stock or loan basis to absorb it, and finds out during an exam. Basis is a running schedule that should update every year, not a calculation done once at a sale.

7. Elections and deadlines that close

The last check is everything that has a date on it:

  • Pass-through entity tax. The federal deduction under Notice 2020-75 depends on when the entity pays, and states set their own election deadlines. Our PTET election guide explains why owners above about $606,000 of MAGI should look hard at it for 2026.
  • Retirement plans. Plan design takes time, and a defined benefit plan means a funding commitment from the year it starts.
  • Timing of large purchases. The 2026 section 179 limit is $2,560,000, reduced once qualifying purchases exceed $4,090,000, per Rev. Proc. 2025-32. Buying equipment on December 31 that the business doesn't need is not planning.
  • Big year-end investments. A large deduction bought under deadline pressure, like a drilling program, gets the least diligence. Our checklist for an oil and gas investment tax deduction applies to any deal pitched on its tax benefit.

Once checks 1 through 6 are clean, the deduction ideas in our 2026 tax deductions guide for service businesses and our list of tax strategies CPAs miss become worth working through.

A ten-minute self-check

Answer each with a yes or no:

  1. Were last month's books closed and reconciled within 20 days of month-end?
  2. Has anyone projected this year's taxable income since midyear?
  3. Was every payroll tax deposit this year made on time?
  4. Was your salary set from a written comparison of what your roles would cost to replace?
  5. Do you have a written accountable plan, and a W-9 on file for every vendor you'll pay $2,000 or more?
  6. Is there a current basis schedule for each shareholder?
  7. Do you know the deadlines for this year's PTET election and any retirement-plan changes?

The first "no" is where to start.

Why the order matters

Running this list backward is the expensive pattern: an owner hears about a strategy, buys it in December, and discovers in April that the estimates were short and the books were wrong. Running it forward costs less, and it's the order our fractional CFO services follow when they take over a company's finance function: close the books, project the year, secure payroll, fix owner pay, then plan.

Pick the first item on the list you can't confidently answer "yes" to. That's your starting point, and probably your biggest exposure. If you aren't sure which one it is, book a Leak Check and get a ranked answer in 20 minutes, before the year's deadlines pass.

Frequently asked questions

Which mistake costs owners the most money?

It varies, but payroll tax problems carry the most personal risk because the trust fund penalty can be assessed against responsible individuals for the full unpaid amount.

How far back can the IRS look at my returns?

Generally three years after the return was filed. That stretches to six years if the return left out more than 25% of gross income, and there is no time limit for a fraudulent return or a return that was never filed, under IRC §6501. Keep records at least that long.

Is it a mistake to file an extension every year?

An extension delays the filing deadline, not the payment deadline. It's fine if the tax is estimated and paid on time; it's a problem when it hides a missing projection.

Should I amend prior returns if I find a mistake?

Often, yes, especially when it's in your favor or reduces penalty exposure. Discuss the cost and benefit of each amendment with your preparer first.

Are cash-basis businesses more likely to make timing mistakes?

Cash basis makes year-end timing easy to shift, which tempts owners to prepay or delay without a plan. The fix is a projection, not a December scramble.

Does using payroll software prevent deposit mistakes?

It helps, but only if the account is funded. Software can't deposit taxes the business doesn't have cash to pay.

What's the most common 1099 mistake for 2026?

Missing W-9s. Without them you can't tell which vendors are corporations or prepare correct forms under the new $2,000 threshold.

How often should an owner review this list?

Quarterly works for most owners: after each month-end close that ends a quarter, before the next estimated payment is due.