Leak Check Identify the likely profit or tax leak to validate first.See what you get

Buy-Sell Agreement Valuation: Formula, Appraisal, or Agreed Value?

Light layered folded sheets beside the purple and dark Sora title Buy-Sell Valuation: Formula, Appraisal, or Agreed Value?.
On this page

Open your operating agreement and find the buy-sell price. If it's a dollar amount, check when it was set. If it's a formula, run it on your worst year in the last five. If it says "fair market value as determined by appraisal," ask who picks the appraiser and who pays.

The price clause almost never gets tested until something has already happened: a death, a disability, a divorce, or a partner who wants out. By then, the owners who could fix it don't agree on anything.

Here's the short version. Use a defined formula as the default, an annual agreed-value certificate that overrides it when it's current, and an independent appraisal as the tie-breaker. Each method alone has a failure mode. Together they cover each other.

This is written for co-owners of $2M–$20M service businesses, such as consulting, IT, professional services, and medical groups, with two to five owners.

The three valuation methods compared

Method How it works Cost to maintain Where it fails
Agreed (fixed) value Owners sign a stated value, ideally updated every year Near zero Nobody updates it, and the price drifts far from reality
Formula A multiple of a defined earnings or revenue figure, less debt Low; an annual calculation One bad year, an undefined term, or a formula that no longer fits the business
Independent appraisal A credentialed appraiser values the company when the trigger happens Fee at each trigger, plus time Slow, can be disputed, and the definition of value may be left vague

Where formulas go wrong: a worked example

Here's a hypothetical three-owner engineering consultancy with $9M of revenue. The agreement says: "Price = 4 × trailing-twelve-month EBITDA × ownership percentage."

In a normal year, EBITDA is about $1.4M. This year, a large project dispute cut EBITDA to $600,000. One owner dies that year.

Basis Company value One-third stake
Formula on trailing 12 months $2.4M $800,000
Same multiple on normalized $1.4M $5.6M ≈ $1.87M

The estate gets $800,000 for a stake worth over twice that in a normal year, and the formula is followed exactly. Now flip it. In a record year, the remaining owners are forced to pay far more than they could finance.

The 4x multiple is illustrative. The structural fixes are what matter:

  • Average the earnings. Use a three-year weighted average (for example, 3-2-1, with the latest year weighted most), not a single trailing year.
  • Define the earnings. Say "adjusted EBITDA" and list the permitted adjustments, including owner compensation at market. The SDE vs EBITDA gap shows how much the owner-pay assumption alone can swing value.
  • Subtract net debt. Otherwise the formula values the company before what it owes.
  • Set a floor and a review date. Revisit the multiple every few years, because what a business like yours sells for changes.

What Connelly changed about funding the buyout

Many buy-sell agreements are funded with life insurance. In Connelly v. United States (2024), the Supreme Court held that a corporation's obligation to redeem a deceased owner's shares at fair market value does not reduce the value of those shares for federal estate tax.

The facts are a warning for any entity-owned policy. The company held $3.5M of life insurance on each of two brothers. After one died, the company used the proceeds to redeem his shares for $3M. The IRS valued the company at $6.86M, including the $3M of proceeds, rather than the $3.86M an analyst produced by excluding them. It valued the deceased brother's 77.18% stake at about $5.3M and assessed $889,914 of additional estate tax.

Two details matter for your agreement:

  1. The owners didn't follow their own price mechanism. The agreement called for an outside appraisal. Instead, the estate and the surviving brother agreed on $3M informally.
  2. Structure changed the result. The Court noted that a cross-purchase arrangement, where each owner holds insurance on the other and buys the shares directly, would have kept the proceeds out of the company's value. It also noted the drawbacks, including each owner paying premiums on the others' policies.

If your agreement is a redemption funded by company-owned insurance, review it with estate counsel. Bring one question: when the company collects the death benefit, does your price count those proceeds as company value or not? If the company owns policies on owner-employees, IRC §101(j) also requires written notice and the insured's written consent before the policy is issued. Without them, the tax-free death benefit can be capped at the premiums paid.

A buy-sell formula is only as good as the earnings number it multiplies. If owner pay, perks, or tax leaks are distorting that number, the price will be wrong for whoever triggers it first. A free Profit & Tax Leak Check shows which of those distortions are in your numbers now, while every owner is still at the table to agree on a fix.

When the IRS can ignore your agreed price

For estate and gift tax, IRC §2703(a) says value is determined without regard to an agreement to acquire property for less than fair market value, or a restriction on its sale. Under §2703(b), your price is respected only if the arrangement meets all three tests:

  1. It is a bona fide business arrangement.
  2. It is not a device to transfer the property to family members for less than full and adequate consideration.
  3. Its terms are comparable to similar arrangements made at arm's length.

This matters most in family-owned businesses, where a low agreed value can look like a transfer. The family-business finance guide covers the governance side. For valuation, the takeaway is simple: a price set by a documented, regularly applied method is easier to defend than a number someone typed in years ago.

Price by trigger, not one price for everything

One clause rarely fits every exit. Many agreements set a base value and then adjust it by trigger:

Trigger Typical design choice Why
Death Full formula or appraised value, funded by insurance The estate shouldn't be penalized, and insurance covers the cash
Disability Full value, longer payment terms Insurance may be partial, so the business needs time
Voluntary departure Value with a discount or longer payout Discourages leaving and protects remaining owners' cash
Termination for cause Lower of formula value or book value Must be clearly defined to survive challenge
Divorce Company or other owners get a right to buy the transferred interest Keeps ownership inside the operating group

Discounts and payout lengths are negotiated, not legally fixed. Before you set them, ask your estate counsel how §2703 and your state's law will treat them.

How the payout gets funded

Value is only half of the clause. The other half is whether the business can pay it. For anything not covered by insurance, the payout is usually an installment note from the company or the remaining owners. Test it the way any lender would. The partner-buyout version of that test is in how to buy out a business partner, and a departing owner receiving installments faces the same credit questions covered in seller financing.

Bennett's rule of thumb: if the remaining owners can't pay the formula price on the payment terms while keeping debt-service coverage at 1.5x or better, the clause is a promise the business can't keep. Either buy more insurance, lengthen the terms, or change the formula now, while everyone is still at the table.

What to do this quarter

Run three numbers:

  1. Your formula price on the last fiscal year, and on the worst of the last five.
  2. Your agreed value, if any, compared with a quick normalized-earnings estimate built the way the two value levers suggest.
  3. The annual payout cost of a full buyout at the formula price, divided into cash flow.

If any of the three surprises you, the clause needs work. Fractional CFO support can build the earnings definition and the payout test that your attorney writes into the agreement. If you'd rather first test whether your earnings are clean enough to anchor a formula at all, a Leak Check looks specifically at the leaks that would distort the price.

Frequently asked questions

How often should owners update the agreed value in a buy-sell agreement?

At least annually, ideally at the same time as the year-end financial review, with every owner signing the certificate. A stale agreed value is the most common way a fixed-price clause fails.

Who chooses the appraiser if the buy-sell agreement calls for an appraisal?

The agreement should say. Common designs name the firm in advance, or have each side choose one appraiser with a third breaking ties. It should also define the standard of value and whether discounts apply.

Should a buy-sell valuation apply minority or marketability discounts?

It is a drafting choice the owners must make explicitly. Applying discounts lowers the price for a departing owner, so many agreements value the whole company and multiply by the ownership percentage instead.

Does the Connelly decision affect LLCs and partnerships?

The case involved a corporation redeeming shares with company-owned life insurance. Any entity-redemption arrangement funded by insurance the entity owns raises a similar valuation question, so review it with estate counsel.

Is a cross-purchase agreement better than a redemption after Connelly?

It can keep insurance proceeds out of the company's value, which the Court noted. It also requires each owner to hold and pay for policies on the others, which gets complicated with more than a few owners.

What happens if a buy-sell agreement has no valuation method?

The owners must negotiate one after the trigger, when their interests are opposed, or a court may end up deciding. Adding a method now is far cheaper than litigating it later.

Can the IRS disregard the price in our buy-sell agreement?

For estate and gift tax, yes, unless the agreement meets all three IRC §2703(b) tests: a bona fide business arrangement, not a device to transfer to family below full value, and terms comparable to arm's-length arrangements.

Should the buy-sell price be different for death and for a voluntary exit?

Often, yes. Death is usually priced at full value and funded with insurance, while voluntary departures commonly carry a discount or longer payout to protect the remaining owners. The terms are negotiated, not fixed by law.