Leak Check Identify the likely profit or tax leak to validate first.See what you get

Fractional CFO for Security Guard Companies: Bill Rates, Overtime, and Contract Margin

Light interlocking rounded loops beside the purple and dark Sora title Fractional CFO for Security Guard Companies.
On this page

A 24/7 post is 168 hours a week. Four full-time guards cover 160. Those last eight hours, and every call-out after them, are where a security guard company's contract margin goes. A fractional CFO for a security guard company does three things a bookkeeper usually doesn't: builds the bill rate from the post-hour up, tracks overtime as a percentage of hours on every contract each week, and funds the payroll float that a new contract creates before the first client payment arrives.

The firms this fits run roughly $2M–$20M of revenue across armed and unarmed posts, patrol and event staffing, mostly for commercial and residential clients on monthly billing. If revenue has grown and profit hasn't, the problem is almost always visible at the post level and invisible in the company P&L.

Why the usual service-business benchmarks don't fit guarding

Most fractional CFO frameworks assume labor is an input. In contract guarding, labor is the product. The client buys hours, and the company's margin is the spread between the bill rate and the fully loaded cost of each hour.

That changes which numbers matter. Bennett's labor efficiency ratio, recognized revenue divided by delivery payroll, uses a 3.5x target for many service firms. A guard company will run well under 2x by design, because nearly every revenue dollar passes through to an hourly wage. Likewise, the 60% gross margin in the 60/15/15 standard isn't a realistic target for staffed posts.

Using those targets here would push an owner to make wrong decisions. The metrics that do work for guarding:

  • Gross margin per billed hour, by contract
  • Overtime hours as a percentage of total paid hours, by contract, weekly
  • Unbilled hours: training, shadow shifts, supervisor coverage the client doesn't pay for
  • Bill-to-pay spread in dollars, not just percent
  • Days from shift worked to cash collected

The post-hour model

Every bid and every renewal should start from one 168-hour post. The figures below are illustrative, not market rates for any region.

Weekly post economics (illustrative) Fully staffed 32-hour vacancy covered with OT
Billed hours 168 168
Bill rate $34.00 $34.00
Weekly revenue $5,712 $5,712
Straight-time hours at $19.00 160 128
Overtime hours at $28.50 8 40
Wages $3,268 $3,572
Payroll burden (assumed 22%) $719 $786
Other direct cost (uniforms, licensing, field supervision) $250 $250
Gross profit $1,475 $1,104
Gross margin 25.8% 19.3%

One unfilled 32-hour slot, covered with overtime, costs this post $371 a week of gross profit, about a quarter of its margin. If that pattern ran across 40 posts all year, it would be roughly $770,000 of gross profit that never appears as a line item. It just looks like "a tough year."

The burden line includes employer FICA. For 2026, IRS Publication 15 sets the employer share at 6.2% social security on wages up to $184,500 plus 1.45% Medicare. The rest of the assumed 22% covers unemployment taxes, workers' compensation and benefits, which vary by state, carrier and classification. Use your actual rates.

Overtime math is set by the workweek

Under the federal Fair Labor Standards Act, covered non-exempt employees must be paid at least one and one-half times their regular rate for hours over 40 in a workweek. The Department of Labor's Fact Sheet #23 defines the workweek as a fixed, regularly recurring period of 168 hours and says averaging hours over two or more weeks isn't permitted.

That last rule hurts guard schedules. A guard who works 48 hours one week and 32 the next is owed eight hours of overtime, even though the two-week total is 80. Rotating 12-hour schedules built for coverage often create overtime on paper that a scheduler didn't notice. Some states add daily overtime rules on top of the federal workweek test, so check your state's labor department before you price a 12-hour post.

What a CFO should put in front of the owner every Monday:

  1. Overtime percentage by contract, last week and trailing four weeks.
  2. Contracts where overtime exceeded the percentage assumed in the bid.
  3. Open positions by site, because vacancies turn straight time into overtime automatically.

A contract bid at 5% overtime and running at 24% isn't a scheduling problem. It's a repricing conversation, or a recruiting budget.

If you can't say which five contracts made the most money last quarter, the margin is leaking somewhere you can't see yet. Bring your bill rates, pay rates and overtime hours to a free Profit & Tax Leak Check and you'll see which contracts are quietly paying for the others.

Build the bill rate up, don't mark the wage up

Many guard companies price as "pay rate plus a markup." That ignores the costs that don't scale with the wage. A bill rate should be built from the post-hour:

Bill rate = (Pay rate × (1 + burden %) × (1 + expected OT premium %)
             + direct cost per hour + unbilled hours per billed hour × loaded rate)
            ÷ (1 − target gross margin %)

Expected OT premium matters. At 10% of hours on overtime, the extra half-time adds about 5% to wage cost. Price it in or the bid is wrong from day one.

Contract terms do as much work as the rate:

  • Holiday and short-notice premiums billed to the client, not absorbed.
  • Wage-change clauses so a minimum-wage or prevailing-wage increase passes through on its effective date, not at renewal.
  • Minimum billable hours for event and temporary posts.
  • Payment terms that match your weekly or biweekly payroll as closely as the client will accept.

The overtime profitability test works through when extra hours stop paying for themselves, and the commercial cleaning CFO guide covers a similar labor-is-the-product model with route density in place of post coverage.

Armed, unarmed, and patrol don't share a margin

Blend them into one company gross margin and the weak line hides behind the strong one. Armed posts carry higher pay, licensing, training hours and insurance cost per hour. Mobile patrol carries vehicles, fuel and response time that a fixed post doesn't. Event staffing has short notice, minimum hours and heavy scheduling overhead. Each needs its own post-hour model and its own minimum margin, and the company P&L should show revenue and gross profit by line every month.

The payroll float on a new contract

Winning a large contract can create a cash problem before it creates a profit. Guards are paid weekly or biweekly. Most clients are billed monthly and pay in 30–60 days.

Illustrative example: a new $1.0M annual contract at a 26% gross margin carries about $14,200 a week of direct labor and cost. Billed at month-end on net-45 terms, the first cash arrives about 75 days after the first shift. That's roughly ten to eleven weeks of payroll the company funds itself, around $150,000, before the contract pays a dollar.

Three contracts like that in one quarter can drain a line of credit that looked comfortable. A fractional CFO models the float before the bid goes in and decides whether the contract needs a deposit, shorter terms, biweekly billing or a credit facility sized for it.

What the engagement covers in a guard company

Area What gets built Decision it supports
Contract P&L Revenue, labor, OT, burden and direct cost by site Which contracts to reprice, renew or exit
Weekly OT report OT % and vacancies by site Scheduling and recruiting spend
Bid model Post-hour bill-rate calculator Price floor for every proposal
Cash forecast 13-week payroll vs collections Credit line size, terms on new contracts
Tax planning Entity, owner pay, timing Owner after-tax cash

Bennett's fractional CFO services are a flat $5,000 a month and include bookkeeping, tax and CFO work in one system, with no tiers. For a guard company, the first 90 days usually focus on the contract P&L, because almost every other decision depends on it.

The number to calculate this week

Take your three largest contracts. For each, divide last month's overtime hours by total paid hours, then rerun the post-hour table above with your real pay rate, burden and bill rate. If any contract is running below the gross margin you'd accept on a new bid, you have a repricing list. If you'd like a second opinion on which contract to tackle first, and what it's costing you while it waits, book a Leak Check and bring those three overtime percentages.

Frequently asked questions

What gross margin should a security guard company target?

There is no single number; it depends on armed vs unarmed work, region, and contract mix. Set a minimum gross margin per billed hour for new bids and measure every contract against it, rather than borrowing a 60% service-business target.

How many guards does it take to staff a 24/7 post?

A 24/7 post is 168 hours a week, so four full-time guards at 40 hours cover 160 and leave 8 hours for overtime or part-time coverage, before training, vacations and call-outs.

Can guard overtime be averaged over a two-week pay period?

Not under the federal FLSA. The DOL says each workweek stands alone and averaging hours over two or more weeks is not permitted; some states add daily overtime rules.

How should a guard company build a bill rate?

Start from the post-hour: pay rate, payroll burden, expected overtime premium, direct cost per hour and unbilled hours, then divide by one minus the target gross margin. A flat markup on wage misses the costs that do not scale with pay.

Why does a big new security contract strain cash?

Guards are paid weekly or biweekly while clients often pay monthly on 30-60 day terms. In the illustration, a $1M contract required about $150,000 of payroll funding before the first payment arrived.

Which report should a guard company owner review weekly?

Overtime hours as a percentage of paid hours by contract, compared with the overtime assumed in the bid, plus open positions by site.

Should wage increases wait until contract renewal?

Not if the contract allows a pass-through. Wage-change clauses let minimum-wage or prevailing-wage increases flow to the bill rate on their effective date instead of eroding margin until renewal.

What does a fractional CFO cost for a security company?

Bennett Financials publishes one price, $5,000 a month, covering bookkeeping, tax and CFO work with no tiers.